How to Choose a Bucket Bag

A bucket bag is one open space and a single shape. That simplicity is the whole appeal, and it's also why fit matters so much. There's no extra pocket to rescue your keys when they sink to the bottom.

1. Empty your current bag

Lay out what you really carry on an average day. Phone, wallet, keys, lip balm, maybe a water bottle or a book. Be honest. This pile is what you're shopping for.

2. Choose the size from that pile

If your pile is small, a mini bucket keeps everything within reach. If it includes a book, a light layer or a bottle, you want the full size. Too much room is its own problem, because small things disappear.

3. Try the closure with one hand

You'll open this bag ten or more times a day, often while holding a coffee. Try opening and closing it one handed before you commit. That's how you'll really use it.

4. Wear it the way you'll wear it

Check how the strap sits over a coat as well as a t shirt, and on the shoulder as well as across the body if you switch between the two.

5. Plan for the small things

Most bucket bags skip inside pockets to keep the shape clean. A small pouch solves this and makes switching bags a ten second job.

6. Give it time to break in

Full grain leather arrives a little stiff. Over the first couple of months of daily use, the sides soften and the bag starts to slouch into its shape. Don't judge it on day one.

The ALVEA bucket bags

The Everyday Bucket Bag ($428) is the full size, and the Everyday Mini Bucket Bag ($328) is the smaller version for lighter days and evenings. Both are full grain Italian leather, handmade in Tuscany. The Everyday Pouch ($128) fits inside either.